More than 500 fans posted their thoughts and here are just some of the names that came up.
Did your favourite player make the list? Email your views to [email protected]
9. Frank Large
British soccer player Frank Large (1940 - 2003), new signing for Fulham FC, with his new manager Bobby Robson (1933 - 2009) 15th June 1968. Frank Large played for Northampton Town in 1962/3, 1966/67 and 1969-1972. (Photo by John Downing/Daily Express/Getty Images) Photo: John Downing
10. Neil 'Larry' Grayson
Neil 'Larry' Grayson, pictured here when he played for Cheltenham Town. Grayson played for Northampton Town between 1994 and 1997. Credit: AllsportUK /Allsport Photo: Getty Images
11. Roy Hunter
Northampton Town's Roy Hunter shows his delight as players celebrate the 4th goal scored by Jamie Forrester during the Nationwide League Division Two match played between Northampton Town (4) and Tranmere Rovers (1) at the Sixfields stadium in Northampton England. DIGITAL IMAGE. Mandatory Credit: Pete Norton / Allsport Photo: Pete Norton
12. Trevor Morley
Trevor Morley, pictured here when he played for West Ham United. Morley played for Cobblers between 1985 and 1988. Credit: Anton Want/Allsport Photo: Anton Want