More than 500 fans posted their thoughts and here are just some of the names that came up.
Did your favourite player make the list? Email your views to [email protected]
1. Roy Hunter
5 Feb 2000: Roy Hunter of Northampton Town during the Nationwide League Division Three match against York City at Sixfields Stadium in Northampton, England. Northampton Town won the game 3-0. Credit: AllsportUK /Allsport Photo: Getty Images
2. Marco Gabbiadini
Marco Gabbiadini of Northampton Town with the match ball after scoring a hat-trick during the Nationwide League Division Two match between Northampton Town and Colchester United played at the Sixfields Stadium, in Northampton, England on September 17, 2002. Northampton Town won the match 4-1. (Photo by Pete Norton/Getty Images) Photo: Pete Norton
3. Martin Smith
Martin Smith of Northampton Town in action during the Coca Cola League Two match between Northampton Town and Swansea City held at Sixfields Stadium, Northampton on March 19, 2005. (Photo by Pete Norton/Getty Images) Photo: Pete Norton
4. John Frain
John Frain of Northampton Town celebrates during the FA Cup 1st round match against Frickley Athletic played at the Sixfields Stadium, in Northampton, England. Northampton Town won the match 4-0. \ Mandatory Credit: Peter Norton /Allsport Photo: Pete Norton