Bristol Bears 41 Northampton Saints 26: Tom Vickers' review and player ratings


Another trip to the Ashton Gate torture chamber didn’t end well for Saints.
This time it was death by a thousand cuts, or rather what felt like a thousand penalties, as the black, green and gold were put to the sword at one of their unhappiest hunting grounds.
Six successive defeats have come at Ashton Gate, a ground where Saints just can’t seem to deliver a performance that is anywhere close to their best.
In the time since their last win there, which came back in November 2021, there has been some mitigation.


They have regularly gone there with a skeleton squad, missing international men due to training camps or injury.
They had a match there that saw Edoardo Todaro dismissed in the opening minute, all but ending their chances of victory on that occasion last November.
But this time, surely they would do better.
Surely the reigning Gallagher PREM champions could put together a performance that wouldn’t let Bristol build up the kind of momentum they thrive on.


At half-time, it looked positive.
Saints had twice conceded tries only to ensure they were the ones who dotted down next.
Setbacks came and they navigated them as they did so often last season, keeping themselves in the fight away from home before more often than not reaching the finishing line first.
And when hugely influential centre Benhard Janse van Rensburg sadly had to leave the field on a stretcher just before the break, with Saints then scoring from the final play of the first half, you really felt this would finally be their day.


The deficit had been cut to one point at 15-14, and Saints surely would emerge with the momentum after half-time, especially as they had the chance to kick off and attempt to pen the Bears in.
But it didn’t happen that way.
Bristol were able to work their way out with two clever kicks and then it was hammer time.
If they had earned a lot of penalties in the first period, that was nothing compared to the amount they enjoyed in the second.
Time after time, they were playing with advantage.
Saints were like a boxer stuck on the ropes, standing up to a right hook only to then be floored by the left.
They could hold out with a penalty coming, but the inevitable would happen as they just could not find a way to relieve the pressure.
Henry Pollock won one breakdown penalty on his own line during the first half, but that was about it.
The Bears showed their bite on the ground and they ensured Saints had some trouble in the air, too.
Referee Ian Tempest continually raised his hand in favour of the hosts, whose intensity secured them three unanswered tries in the opening 21 minutes of the second half, pushing them into a 34-14 lead with 19 minutes to go.
The real Saints then seemed to stand up as they gave themselves a slim chance to mounting a comeback, playing with the kind of tempo and ability that made them kings of England last season.
Alex Mitchell was at the heart of it as he scored before Josh Kemeny's effort bagged the try bonus point with 12 minutes to go.
At eight points down, suddenly it didn’t all look so bleak and Saints surely had a sniff.
Wrong.
More errors – the lineout did not go well - and a lack of control, along with those dreaded penalties, allowed Bristol to take back control.
And two yellow cards in the closing stages brought the curtain down on another Ashton Gate encounter to forget, with the hosts being awarded a penalty try from the final play of the game to really rub salt in the wounds.
It was a game in which Saints only led once, from the 10th to the 15th minute, as Bristol again got in the ascendancy at their home ground and refused to let Saints enjoy an advantage, something the Bears did a lot.
It seems so strange that the record is as it is, because you would feel these kinds of games would suit Saints.
A nice surface, a big stadium, a venue where the home supporters are hardly right on top of you, a home team who like to open the game up.
All the ingredients are there for Saints to strike at the heart of the Bears, but they just can’t seem to do it.
Again, full credit must go to Pat Lam’s men, because they are a force to be reckoned with, as they showed when winning at Sale Sharks on opening day.
And they certainly don’t get enough credit for the way they do the gritty parts of the game.
They are a collective menace at the breakdown, they maul as well as anyone in the league, living up to their Bears tag, and they defended in a far more disciplined manner than Saints.
Yet you just feel this was a day, more than the other defeats before it, where the black, green and gold will really rue what unfolded.
But there is little time to lick the wounds because another big, brutal challenge lies in wait back home, with perennial title challengers Bath coming to town.
And Saints will know they will have to be so much better in every area of their game if they are to gather a victory that would be so significant even at this formative stage of the season.
How they rated…
TOMMY FREEMAN – one of the quietest afternoons you will see this man have in an attacking sense. His frustration eventually peaked when he took out Louis Rees-Zammit to earn a yellow card and hand the Bears a penalty try from the final play of the game… 4.5
OLLIE SLEIGHTHOLME – the decision to bring this man in seemed a sensible one given his experience on the big stage, but it turned out to be a really tough afternoon as penalties went against him and he saw a big scoring chance elude him as he knocked on from a tough bouncing pass… 4
RORY HUTCHINSON – as he did against Newcastle on the previous weekend, his showcased a clever passing game that knitted the Saints attack together when he got the chance… 6
FRASER DINGWALL – fronted up, as he always does, and produced a nice pass to open the door for George Hendy to set up Alex Mitchell during the second half but couldn’t have the overall influence he would have liked… 5.5
GEORGE HENDY – bagged himself two tries during the first half and also delivered a good assist during the second period but didn’t get much fortune with the bounce of the ball when Bristol kicked clear on a couple of occasions… 6.5
FIN SMITH – with Bristol’s defence depriving Saints of options, he went to the boot on several occasions, but nothing really came off in that regard. Two of his touchline conversions were impressive and he did some good things in open play but without much reward… 5.5
ARCHIE MCPARLAND – spent a lot of time in breakdowns rather than at the back of them during the first period as he tried to carry his team forward with ball in hand, but Bristol got back well… 5
MANNY IYOGUN – seemed to suffer a hand injury at one point, adding to the overall pain on an afternoon when he couldn’t have the influence he had against Newcastle… 5
CURTIS LANGDON – was perhaps unfortunate to be penalised for obstruction as Saints saw a try ruled out and it wasn’t a day he or his team-mates will remember fondly… 5
CLEOPAS KUNDIONA – showcased some good passing but was unfortunate to knock on at one point as Bristol put huge pressure on Saints… 5
ALEX COLES – thought he’d scored during the second half but it was ruled out for obstruction in the build up. Kept ploughing on but didn’t get much change from the Bears defence… 5.5
ED PROWSE – the big man made some big carries, particularly during the first period, but Bristol didn’t get sucked in and dealt with Saints’ power threat well… 5.5
JOSH KEMENY – bagged the bonus-point try for Saints and threatened one of those trademark breaks during the first period, but Bristol largely kept hold of him… 5.5
JOSH TAYLOR – a first Gallagher PREM start for the back row forward, who did superbly to pouch one crossfield kick but who was met with some fierce resistance… 5
HENRY POLLOCK – popped up to win a huge penalty on his own line but saw plenty of breakdown decisions go against him and saw one pass intercepted in the first period, which was one he’d love to have back with Saints looking certain to score… 5
Replacements (who played more than 20 minutes)
ROBBIE SMITH (for Langdon 50) – was penalised for reacting after Bristol fanned the flames, but he carried with venom when he got the chance… 5
DANILO FISCHETTI (for Iyogun 50) – couldn’t really have an impact on this game… 5
ION NECULAI (for Kundiona 50) – a lovely piece of play during the build-up to Kemeny’s try but then knocked on, gave away a penalty and was sin-binned so it proved to be a tough afternoon overall… 4
CALLUM CHICK (for Taylor 50) – added a bit of force but was so unfortunate with a bouncing ball that allowed Bristol to knock him back over his own line and was also penalised for head on head contact… 5
ALEX MITCHELL (for McParland 54) – really helped Saints to lift the tempo, showing his class during what was a try-scoring cameo… 7
JAMES PATER (for Sleightholme 54) – delivered one of the best 50:22s you will see and didn’t shy away from the battle with Saints under pressure… 6
CHRON STAR MAN – Louis Rees-Zammit (Bristol Bears)