Clear-cut chances and free-flowing football were in short supply on a blustery afternoon in Stoke-on-Trent as both sides created and missed one big chance apiece. Here are our player ratings from Vale Park...
9. Cameron McGeehan
Had the only serious chance of the first half - for either team - when his header was well saved by Gauci. Tough going for the front men but he kept making runs and offering an outlet... 7 Photo: Pete Norton
10. Tyrese Fornah
Wasn't a day for flair players of his ilk to shine as conditions ultimately proved too much to overcome. The big pitch and scrappy nature of the game limited his influence. Taken off for Swyer midway through the second half... 6.5 Photo: Pete Norton
11. Ethan Wheatley
Nothing wrong with his first half performance, he held the ball up when needed and made good runs, but did not re-emerge for the second half... 6.5 Photo: Pete Norton
12. Jack Vale
Picked up Wheatley's role to good effect. Best moment came when he nicked the ball back in the press and drove forward. Should have shot but opted to pass and forced Taylor too wide. He's sprightly and lively though... 6.5 Photo: Pete Norton