Here are our player ratings from the PTS...
9. Mark Marshall
Kept plugging away without reward. Put good balls into dangerous areas time and again and his trickery worked space around the box, creating a good chance for Oliver. Had a decent claim for a penalty too... 7.5 CHRON STAR MAN | Getty Photo: Pete Norton
10. Callum Morton
Vale's excellent defence kept him in check bar one snapshot into the side-netting, even if some of their marking was a little over exuberant. So close to snaffling up the rebound from Adams' shot... 6 | Getty
11. Vadaine Oliver
Probably forced Brown into his best stop during an impressive performance between the sticks, a terrific reflex save from the striker's volleyed effort. Not many defences have matched him for physicality as well as Vale did... 6.5 | Getty Photo: Pete Norton
12. Andy Williams
Sent on for Morton to find a goal but unfortunately made little impact... 6 | Getty