Nolan explains reason for replacing Thorniley with Dyche in first half of Plymouth win

Kevin Nolan has explained why he made the decision to withdraw Jordan Thorniley in the first half of Saturday’s 3-0 win at Plymouth Argyle.

The 29-year-old on-loan Oxford defender, making his 10th successive league start, was booked after only five minutes at Home Park for kicking a second ball onto the pitch in order to stop Plymouth from taking a quick throw-in, before a lapse of concentration allowed Bali Mumba to nip in and go close.

Thorniley was then adjudged to have committed another foul, and whilst the decision seemed a little harsh, he was perhaps fortunate not to pick up a second yellow given the situation, especially with Plymouth fans and players baying for red.

With no red card forthcoming, Nolan then made the sensible decision to replace Thorniley with Max Dyche, and it proved the correct call as Cobblers eased to victory and kept a clean sheet in the process.

Jordan Thornileyplaceholder image
Jordan Thorniley

"It's great to have options on the bench and the reason why I took Jud off in the first half and put Max on was because I felt they were working hard to try and get him sent off and we didn't want to take that risk,” explained Nolan.

"No disrespect but I don't think I could have kept him on the pitch because I didn't know what the referee was going to do so we had to get him off. Jud's obviously got the character and experience to manage those situations but all it takes is one mistimed challenge and he’s off.

"The crowd wanted him off and there was one foul but to be honest I didn't think it was even a foul. It was a collision where Jud's slipped and those things happen.

"I was very surprised that the linesman was so quick to put his flag up on a few occasions today because I felt he could have let it go a bit more, but our lads managed those situations really well and in the end we came away with a very good away win.”

News you can trust since 1931
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice