Dyche header secures precious point as Cobblers fight back to draw at Barnsley

Cobblers arrested their losing run with a hard-earned and much-needed 2-2 draw against Barnsley at Oakwell on Tuesday.

The evening couldn’t have started any better with Nesta Guinness-Walker tapping home after just three minutes, but Town’s defending left a lot to be desired at times in the first half as they struggled to stop balls coming into their penalty box.

Tyrese Fornah in action for Cobblers at Barnsley (Picture: Pete Norton)placeholder image
Tyrese Fornah in action for Cobblers at Barnsley (Picture: Pete Norton)

One of countless crosses led to David McGoldrick levelling half-an-hour in, however Kevin Nolan's side improved significantly in the second half and they could easily have won it despite falling behind.

Adam Phillips scored with his first touch to give Barnsley the lead but Cobblers responded impressively and they were deservedly rewarded thanks to a Max Dyche header 18 minutes from the end.

It's now eight without a win in the league but this can only be seen as a good point and Cobblers must now built on it to get themselves out of trouble at the bottom of League One.

Deadline day signings Kyle McAdam and Ben Hammond were not eligible, while Elliott Moore (personal reasons), Jake Evans (selection) and skipper Jon Guthrie (injury) also missed out, but Cameron McGeehan returned to the starting line-up in one of six changes from the weekend, and Tyrese Fornah was back on the bench.

Nolan picked an entirely new back three of Max Dyche, Jordan Willis and Michael Forbes, with Joe Wormleighton recalled at wing-back and Jack Vale leading the line.

On a bitterly cold, foggy evening in Yorkshire, Cobblers made the perfect start.

Not even three minutes were on the clock when Vale pinched the ball just outside the penalty box and squared for McGeehan, and though his shot was saved, the rebound dropped on a plate for Guinness-Walker to gleefully tap in.

Knocked by the early setback, there was a real anxiety and nervousness to Barnsley’s play in the first quarter, and even when they did enjoy some settled possession, their attacking play was erratic, but Cobblers could not capitalise on an increasingly restless atmosphere.

Naturally, the hosts played their way into the game and the chances started flow, with Vimal Yoganathan lifting over the bar, Scott Banks curling off target and Patrick Kelly lashing high and wide.

Cobblers dropped deeper and deeper and invited pressure, and so it came as no surprise when they were pegged back on the half-hour with a goal that was just far too easy, another set-piece their undoing as McGoldrick simply ran off his marker and flicked home Banks’ free-kick.

The one source of encouragement for Cobblers was that Barnsley did look vulnerable at the back, and the visitors almost retook the lead straightaway after more fine work by Vale, but McGeehan drilled just wide.

Defensive errors continued to undermine Town, however, and Dyche was given a huge let-off seven minutes before half-time when his error sent Yoganathan though on goal, but the Barnsley man failed to even hit the target.

The second half started with Barnsley having virtually all of the ball but Cobblers had tightened up defensively, although Yoganathan did head over.

Nolan made a triple change on the hour as McCarthy, Fornah and Swyer all came on, but Barnsley also made a substitution at the same time and their replacement had an immediate impact.

Phillips had been on the pitch a matter of seconds when he was quickest to react after McGoldrick’s shot deflected off Wormleighton, sprinting between two defenders and slotting past Ross Fitzsimons.

Cobblers responded rally well and had a flurry of chances in the minutes after going behind with Vale, Fornah and and Elliott List, only just on, all seeing shots blocked, before the equaliser came 18 minutes from the end.

A corner was recycled, Wormleighton floated in a cross and Swyer headed on for Dyche to nod beyond Owen Goodman and into the net for an equaliser.

The game was now anyone’s for the taking and Cobblers looked just as likely as the home side, although Barnsley did have a decent penalty shout waved away after Fornah tangled Tykes player in the box.

Fornah saw a shot blocked and several corners were smuggled away by Barnsley as both sides had to be content with a point apiece.

Match facts

Barnsley: Goodman, O’Keeffe, O’Connell, Shepherd, Watson (Ogbeta 77), Bland, Yoganathan (Phillips 61), Banks, Kelly, Cleary, McGoldrick. Subs not used: Flavell, Farrell, de Gevigney, Roberts, Chirewa

Cobblers: Fitzsimons, Dyche, Willis (McCarthy 60), Forbes (Eaves 69), Wormleighton, Guinness-Walker, Taylor, Campbell, McGeehan (Fornah 60), Hoskins (Swyer 60), Vale (List 69). Subs not used: Burge, Perkins

Referee: Thomas Parsons

Attendance: 8,806

Cobblers fans: 247

News you can trust since 1931
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice