Contentious penalty condemns shot-shy Cobblers to home defeat against Rotherham

Cobblers’ difficult start to the new season continued when they were beaten by Paul Mullin’s controversial second half penalty in Saturday’s game against Rotherham United.

Town’s performance in the first half was night and day compared to last weekend as they played with more energy and conviction and also looked to go forward quicker, leading to a number of dangerous situations.

placeholder image
Pete Norton

Once again, however, they barely created anything in terms of serious, genuine chances, and they were also indebted to their goalkeeper for a couple of good saves at either end of the first half to keep it goalless.

But there was nothing Zach Jeacock could do about Mullin’s emphatic spot-kick 17 minutes from full-time, awarded to the away side for a foul by Max Dyche that looked to have happened outside the penalty area.

Nonetheless, the result leaves Cobblers 22nd in League Two, just one place outside the bottom two with six points from seven games. They now have three weeks until they next play in the league.

An injury to James Maxwell meant a Cobblers debut for Josh Powell, who started at left wing-back as Chris Hogg switched system. Sam Chambers, Dyche and Owen Dale also came into the side, with Logan Briggs and Sam Hoskins joining Connor Evans on the bench.

Rotherham were first to threaten when Jeacock had to be at full stretch to claw away Fabio Tavares, but Town were the better side for much of the first half and they went close through Nathan Opoku, who was denied by an excellent last-ditch tackle.

Dale lifted over from 20 yards after a nicely-worked corner and another well-timed challenge denied Joe O’Brien-Whitmarsh a shot at goal in a promising flurry for the home side.

Northampton’s aggressive and energetic pressing was forcing the visitors into errors, one of which led to a free-kick that saw Dyche head too close to Millers goalkeeper Julian Eyestone.

Opoku and Dale were combining well down the right and the former got in behind again but took too long to get a shot off and allowed a defender to recover.

For all of the good stuff though, Cobblers could easily have found themselves trailing at the break after a defensive mix-up shortly allowed Josh Austerfield a clear shot at goal, but Jeacock reacted smartly to keep the scores level going into half-time.

The interval came at a good time for Rotherham and they were able to reverse the momentum once play restarted, with Jeacock again called up, first to thwart Mullin and then to claw away a dangerous cross.

The visitors had more of a share of the game in the second half although the contest became increasingly scrappy and frenetic as time ticked away.

But the key moment came with 17 minutes to go. Mullin got the wrong side of Dyche and the Town defender dragged him down, with the referee deeming it to be just inside the penalty box despite replays suggesting otherwise. Mullin made no mistake from the spot, smashing emphatically into the top corner.

Austerfield almost added a quick second, firing into the side-netting, and Rotherham also had a couple of further chances, before Cobblers attempted to rally late on but struggled to build sustained momentum.

The home side did carve out one big chance to snatch a point in stoppage-time when Harvey Saunders raced onto a loose ball and was through on goal, but he failed to beat Eyestone and that confirmed another pointless and goalless afternoon for Chris Hogg’s side.

Cobblers: Jeacock, Dyche (Warhurst 81), Moore, Guthrie (c), Wormleighton, Powell, Fornah (Hoskins 87), O’Brien-Whitmarsh, Dale (Briggs 81), Chambers (Saunders 68), Opoku (C Evans 87)

Subs not used: Fitzsimons, Swyer

Rotherham: Eyestone, Otoo, Iorfa (Buyabu 60), Austerfield, Ashley (Spence 67), Tavares (Bradshaw 67), Hall, Aljofree, Nemane (Ngwenya 79), Cover, Mullin (c) (Adegboyega 79)

Subs not used: Cann, Fitzgerald

Referee: Will Finnie

Attendance: 5,771

Rotherham fans: 716

News you can trust since 1931
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice