Abject Cobblers thrashed by Burton after horrific defensive display

Cobblers turned in one of their worst defensive performances in recent memory when humiliated 5-1 by Burton Albion on Boxing Day.

After being given Christmas Day off by their manager, Northampton’s all-at-sea defence did not look anywhere near ready for the challenge as a catalogue of inexplicable errors led to four shocking goals in the first 44 minutes.

Tom Eavesplaceholder image
Tom Eaves

Nesta Guinness-Walker gifted Burton a late Christmas present when conceding a penalty inside three minutes, converted by Jake Beesley, and more slapstick defending allowed Jack Armer to make it 2-0.

Max Dyche’s absurd own goal – the worst of the lot – meant it was three with less than half an hour played, and whilst Tom Eaves headed in to briefly restore hope, Tyrese Shade’s fourth completed an embarrassing 45 minutes of football.

A seething Nolan made one substitution in the first half and a further three at half-time but his side never threatened a comeback and their misery was compounded by Shade scoring a fifth late on.

Nolan stuck with the same XI that started the second half of last week’s win over Wimbledon, which meant Dean Campbell and Michael Forbes dropped to the bench and Kamarai Swyer and Max Dyche both came in.

Cobblers were behind with only three minutes on the clock at the Pirelli as Conor McCarthy’s ill-advised pass across his own penalty box was followed by a mistimed challenge from Guinness-Walker. Referee Sam Mulhall wasted no time in pointing to the spot and Beesley fired down the middle of the goal.

Sloppy with the ball and slack without it, Town were nowhere near the races in the first half and more woeful defending led to a second Burton goal on 24 minutes. Sam Hoskins inadvertently played in Armer and though Ross Fitzsimons kept out his first effort, Dyche’s inadequate clearance ricocheted back to him and he made no mistake at the second time of asking.

It was to get worse with an even more ludicrous goal on the half-hour. A simple free-kick was lofted into Town’s penalty box, no defender dealt with it and McCarthy's attempted clearance hit Dyche and rebounded into the net for a comical own goal.

Cobblers missed a glorious chance to pull one back when Cameron McGeehan somehow hit the crossbar from three yards before Nolan made a first half substitution for the second game in a row, hooking McCarthy and sending on Jack Burroughs.

The visitors gave themselves flicker of hope late in the first half as Eaves glanced in Terry Taylor’s cross but that was extinguished on the cusp of half-time as the Northampton defence disappeared and Shade slotted through Fitzsimons’ legs.

Nolan was furious on the touchline and he made three further changes at the break, sending on Forbes, Elliott List and Jordan Willis in place of Hoskins, Jordan Thorniley and Dyche.

McGeehan shot over at the start of the second half while Terence Vancooten was lucky to still be on the pitch following poor challenges on Ethan Wheatley and List, but instead it was Northampton who finished the game with 10 men after Forbes picked up an injury when Nolan had already made all five subs.

And to cap a woeful afternoon, Shade raced away to score his second and Burton’s fifth on the counter-attack with six minutes to play.

Cobblers: Fitzsimons, McCarthy (Burroughs 38), Dyche (List 45), Thorniley (Willis 45), Hoskins © (Forbes 45), Guinness-Walker, Taylor, McGeehan, Swyer, Wheatley (Edwards 76), Eaves

Subs not used: Burge, Campbell

Referee: Sam Mulhall

Attendance:

Cobblers fans:

News you can trust since 1931
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice