The John Griff Column: Leadership – defined?


On this week – of all weeks – a lot has been said about teamworking and leadership. Now, as the week of Remembrance Day and Armistice Day nears its end, what have we witnessed about the nature of leadership and its values? Who and what are the exemplars and how perhaps has the nature of leadership changed? Is it for the better?
On Remembrance Sunday I had the honour of attending the annual Act of Remembrance in the country village of Great Brington. Looking out over both the rolling Northamptonshire countryside and the Althorp estate, the church there is impressive in its understated architectural style as the church of the Spencer family and many more besides. Its nearby cenotaph was built in 1921 from Weldon stone and in the style of the Whitehall cenotaph. Many from the village attended, listening as the names of the fallen were read out and the two minute silence was observed - a fitting tribute, followed by a well-attended church service. Bringing the event to fruition in the 80th anniversary year of the end of World War II must have taken lots of planning and leadership. Credit to those who managed it, therefore. It was delivered exactly as it always should be.
On the same day though, came news of a different kind.
It is never good when a news organisation becomes, itself, the news of the day. And yet, the BBC became exactly that. Director General Tim Davie and CEO of BBC News Deborah Turness both resigned their posts. Their departures followed mounting pressure after a leaked memo alleged how a Donald Trump speech before the 2021 storming of the Capitol Building in Washington had been edited for Panorama, misrepresenting what POTUS said in full and the order of his words. The memo, written by ex-BBC adviser Michael Prescott, set out a number of claims and was leaked to the Telegraph newspaper. Mr Trump (a noted litigator against the media before) has issued a threat to sue the corporation, apparently to the tune of $1bn. At the time of writing it remains to be seen what happens – but there are precedents.
The affair has cast light on the independence and impartiality of the BBC – something which the now former DG made a cornerstone of his time in post. The BBC is a very large target to take aim at – daily its website is besieged by those trying to hack it. Many have accused it of editorial bias in a variety of ways over many years. For all that though, it has always been generally accepted as being one of, if not THE benchmark for independent, truthful reporting. If the BBC said something was a certain way, you could believe it. Many in Westminster this week have rushed to state that you still can.
But that kitemark position is now under threat, and at the worst possible time. The BBC is nearing the renewal of its government charter. Crucial to its future funding and the way it serves a global audience, it simply cannot afford to be seen or thought of as being untrustworthy. In my own time at BBC Radio Northampton, I never witnessed any direction to report, edit or otherwise represent any story in a particular way, or contrary to what I understood (through research) to be the truth. Like every other member of the team there, I underwent formal training to reinforce the BBC’s impartiality and balance – as such I completely believe in my former colleagues and their integrity.
But I am troubled by the former Director General’s own words. Justifying his decision to go, Tim Davie said that he was taking ‘…ultimate responsibility…’ for recent events. His CEO of News did the same – and resigned. Would it not have been a greater demonstration of leadership – and determination – for both to have acknowledged the issues thrown up by the Panorama speech edit and stayed the course to oversee restorative action? Both could have remained in post and the demonstrable resolve to put things right would have counted for a great deal. Instead, the BBC is now without a Director General and the head of perhaps its most important division. The BBC Board is left facing the challenge of replacing both at a time when scrutiny of the BBC and its activities is at its most forensic. If, in World War 1, the equivalent had happened within the armed forces, where would we have ended up?
Great leaders lead through the good and more challenging times. Departure is NOT taking ultimate responsibility – staying to put things right, is.