Councillors have rejected a bid to offer a "spare Northamptonshire's libraries" option to the public as part of a proposal to cut £10million from services.
Northamptonshire County Council has put forward three options for consultation on how the axe will fall on public libraries, all of which would close at least 21 of them.
The choices have been met with condemnation from Northamptonshire folk and opposition parties, who have defended them as "essential" community centres.
At a full county council meeting today (November 23), Liberal Democrat councillor Chris Stanbra made a motion to introduce "option four" and offer the public the choice to ask for no cuts at all to libraries.
However, it was defeated 32 to 10 against. The bulk of votes against came from Conservative councillors.
Sign the Chronicle & Echo's petition for the Government to review spending in Northamptonshire.
The proposals have also put forward that libraries could be handed over and run by community groups if they are dropped by the council.
Councillor Dennis Meredith, deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats, told the full council: "Librarians are very skilled people. Libraries must have paid, professional staff. To say that libraries can just be handed over to community groups is absolute madness.
"If you close these libraries, you will be the worst county council in the country."
Over a dozen members of the public, Northampton borough councillors and county councillors spoke at the meeting to appeal for "option four", including Northamptonshire author Sue Bentley.
Speaking against the option, councillor Sylvia Hughes said: "An option of 'do nothing' is not viable.
"Northamptonshire is one of the last county councils in the country to review their libraries.
"Please, everyone, please use the consultation to put forward what you've said here today so it can be properly analysed and considered."