Pensioner has hammer attack sentence reduced
A debt-ridden Northamptonshire pensioner who battered a 68-year-old neighbour over the head with a hammer today had his "excessive" six-year sentence slashed by top judges in London.
David Harrison McArthur, 70, of Warminster Close, Corby, hit Patricia Mitchell, who he had known for more than 30 years, at least three times after an argument about money.
The gambling addict was jailed for six years at Northampton Crown Court in April after admitting wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.
But, in a hearing at the Court of Appeal, two top judges, Mr Justice Jack and Mr Justice Blake, ruled the sentence "manifestly excessive" and slashed it to four-and-a-half years.
Mr Justice Blake said McArthur's age and previous good character justified a reduction in a sentence which would have been appropriate for a younger offender.
McArthur had been an industrious, law-abiding man, who had lived a "blameless" life until he retired and developed a crushing gambling problem, the judge told the court.
He quickly amassed debts running into five figures, including borrowing between 300 and 500 cash from his neighbour, Mrs Mitchell.
Last November 12, he went around to her house, carrying a hammer and intending to talk about the debt, but instead fell into argument.
He then hit her at least three times over the head with the hammer, causing bloody injuries and lasting psychological damage to Mrs Mitchell.
Sentencing him, the Crown Court judge found that, although he had taken the hammer with him to the scene of the attack, he was not set on violence when he went.
Today, his lawyers argued that the six-year term was too long and succeeded in convincing the two judges to reduce the sentence to four-and-a-half years.
Mr Justice Blake said: "But for the fact that this was a man of 70, of very positive good character, with no hint of violence or any other form of offending, with a good history of neighbourliness until this dramatic and terrifying incident, the sentence could not possibly be the subject of criticism.
"For those reasons, and only those reasons, recognising the appalling nature of the violence, nevertheless, we think that the sentence is manifestly excessive.
"We propose to quash the sentence of six years and substitute for it a sentence of four-and-a-half years."
Email to a friend
Print this page- BREAKING NEWS: Man dies following motorway smash on Northamptonshire border
- BREAKING NEWS: Police inundated with hundreds of complaints over snowball fights
- Huge cigarette haul by masked burglars in armed raids at Northampton stores
- BREAKING NEWS: Police name man killed in crash on motorway in Northamptonshire
- Student flats planned for Northampton town centre revealed
- BREAKING NEWS: Fishmarket art gallery offered new home
- Student flats planned for Northampton town centre revealed
- New manager of Northampton’s Grosvenor Centre says ‘This is the beginning of a new era’
- BREAKING NEWS: Police inundated with hundreds of complaints over snowball fights
- Neighbours raise concern about bid to build new house three inches from their home
- Exclusive: Saints voluntarily move key Heineken Cup match to Milton Keynes
- Bird’s hilarious take on village life absurdities at comedy club
- Northampton commuters blast railway fare rises
- Sooty may be left with bullet in neck following senseless attack
- Ashton determined to end Saints career on a high
Looking for...
Featured advertisers
Jobs
Search for a job
Motors
Search for a car
Property
Search for a house
Weather for Northampton
Friday 10 February 2012
Today
Sunny spells
Temperature: -6 C to 1 C
Wind Speed: 13 mph
Wind direction: South east
Tomorrow
Sunny spells
Temperature: -5 C to -0 C
Wind Speed: 7 mph
Wind direction: South east
